Franco Naccarella*, Giovannina Lepera, Fabio Iachetti, Antonella Bartoletti, Mauro Gatti, Mario Coluccini, Pietro Ticci***, Luigi Padeletti***, Andrea Nava**.
*Cardiology Department, Azienda USL della Citta di Bologna, Bologna, **Cardiology, University of Padova, ***Clinical Electrophysiology, Clinica Medica, University of Firenze, Italy
|
|
In recent papers, it has been proposed that Brugada’s syndrome (BS)
might be due to genetically determined Na channels pathology, in the absence of an otherwise demonstrable
heart disease1-62.
Nevertheless, cases with minor anatomical pathological features of the right ventricle and infundibulum have
been reported, with a negative genetic screening, for the typical chromosome localizations documented in right
ventricular dysplasia cardiomyopathy (RVDC)1,2. Furthermore, some cases that have displayed the typical
Brugada ST T pattern, in the absence of an organic heart disease, later evolved into manifest RVDC47. In other
cases, with a clinical diagnosis of RVDC46-48, a comcomitant Brugada ECG pattern has been shown. In these
cases, an underlying concomitant Na channels pathology and RVDC chromosomes mutation can be postulated.
Alternatively, a new chromosome localization for RVDC should be suspected. In these cases, a specific
involvement of the high right ventricle or of the right infundibulum should be postulated in association with the
typical localizations of the RVDC (apex, area behind the tricuspid valve, and infundibular area under pulmonary
valves)20,26-32,34,44-47.
Thus, both a primary form of BS without any sign of organic heart disease1-3,6,7,12,14,17 and a secondary form of
the disease, due to an initial pattern of RVDC should be suspected1,2,61,62.
TABLE I – Differential features in the Brugada’s syndrome and RVDC (modified from Brugada)
| |
Right Ventricular
Dysplasia
Cardiomyopathy
|
Brugada’s syndrome
|
Age
|
Any
|
Any
|
Sex
|
M>F
|
M>F
|
Hereditary disorder
|
+++
|
++
|
ECG 1
|
Negative T wave in V1 V3
|
Incomplete RBBB/ST T elevation
|
ECG 2
|
Epsilon wave fixed changes
|
Elevated ST or J point dynamic changes
|
ECG 3
|
Different aspects in the same family
|
Similar aspects
|
| |
|
Different RBBB degree
|
| |
|
Different ST elevation extent
|
Arrhythmias
|
Monomorphic VT
|
Polymorphic VT
|
| |
|
VF
|
| |
Frequent EVBs
|
Sporadic or no EVBs
|
HV interval
|
Normal if nor RBBB
|
Abnormal in 1/3
|
Ajmaline
|
Non tested
|
Further ST T elevation secondary to the increase in intraventricular
|
| |
No effects (?)
|
conduction delay (?) secondary to the effects on Na channels (?)
|
Isoproterenol
|
No effects
|
Normalization
|
Echo/angio
|
RV dilatation
|
Normal, mild RV dilatation
|
| |
RV aneurysm
|
Infundibular tract dilatation
|
| |
Loss of RV Trabeculae
|
Wall thickness reduction
|
| |
Fibrous-adipous infiltration
|
No fibrous-adipous infiltration
|
NMR
|
Adipous infiltration as above
|
As above
|
| |
|
Frequently normal
|
PET SCAN
|
?
|
Normal
|
Histo-pathological aspects
|
Adipous infiltration, reduced
|
Normal, reduced myocardial thickness
|
| |
|
myocardial fibrosis
|
ECG 1, 2, 3=ECG aspects; Echo/angio=echocardiographic and angiographic aspects; NMR=NMR
features; PET SCAN=positron emission tomography aspects.
|