Xavier Vinolas, Salvador Olmos**, Jose L. Alonso, Pere Caminal*, Pablo Laguna**, AntonioBayés de Luna.
Cardiology Department, Hospital Sant Pau, Barcelona, *Centre de Recerca Bioengenieria, Universitat Barcelona, **Facultad Ingenieria, Universidad Zaragoza, Spain
|
|
TWA detection methods
All detection methods need the following common steps:
1) preprocessing: used to eliminate the non useful components of the ECG signal, for example the variations of
the baseline signal)10;
2) QRS detection and segmentation of ST-ST segment: the step is crucial, because the beginning of the QRS
should be similar for all beats11;
3) noise detection: in order to eliminate the noisy beats;
4) low pass filter: used to eliminate the frequency components >40 Hz.
Fast Fourier transform methods
This was the first method used to detect alternans and is the most widely used. But some limitations are present,
and some authors prefer the correlation method (see later)12. The most important factors influencing the FFT
result:
– ectopic beats;
– incorrect alignment of QRS complexes;
– noisy beats.
The most important advantages of the FFT method is the simplicity to implement the analysis and the low
computer calculations needed. The limitations are those of the FFT analysis: 1) the assumption of a stationary
signal, when TWA is clearly non-stationary; 2) the relationship between temporal resolution and frequency
resolution. When time interval is reduced (typically to n=128) we can assume that the signal is stationary; but
signal resolution is worse with short time intervals; 3) we cannot find TWA amplitude (in microvolts) for each
beat; 4) we do not have information regarding the morphology of T wave.
Complex demodulation method
The system uses a high pass filter of the ST-T segments correctly aligned. Two kinds of filters are used:
– deterministic filter
– statistic filter16.
The most important advantages of this system are: 1) better temporal/frequency resolution compared to FFT
analysis and 2) it allows to analyse the morphology of the alternating signal.
Correlation method
This method was proposed by Burattini et al. Summarizing, a template of ST segment (median of the signal in
the 128 consecutive signals) is create in the 128 beats sequence. The correlations of the beats with the template
are analysed. One of the advantages is that the system is strongest for misalignment of QRS complexes and
concentrates all information regarding the ST-T segment in a single number. The use of the median QRS
complex as the template could represent a limitation.
KLT based method
The method based on the Karhunen-Loeve transform allows to represent the information regarding signal
analysed in a short number of coefficients20,21. Our group has used this type of analysis for ST changes detection
during PTCA22-26 and alternans detection27,28. Once the different coefficients representing each beat are
obtained, we only represent the component with a period each two beats. We propose the high pass filter statistic
method of Capon16. The method is more solid than the correlation method against noisy beats and allows a
better representation of the “morphology”. We can also obtain using this method the duration and amplitude of
the “alternating” period.
|